AutoShelf vs Hazel: Which file organizer is right for you?
Hazel has been the go-to Mac file organizer for years. AutoShelf is a modern alternative designed for macOS Sonoma and later. Here is how they compare.
Download for MacPublished · Updated
Which is better, AutoShelf or Hazel?
It depends on how much scripting you need. If you want regex conditions, AppleScript or shell script actions, or you already have a large Hazel rule library, Hazel is the better choice. If you want ready-made templates, rules that route files by the app that downloaded them, built-in JPG and PNG optimization, and a lower price, AutoShelf is the better choice. As of October 2026, Hazel costs $42 per license with a 14-day trial, and AutoShelf is free with 1 rule or $19.99 one-time for unlimited rules.
Two approaches to file organization
- Hazel is a mature, powerful automation tool with regex rules and deep customization. It has a steeper learning curve.
- AutoShelf is a modern macOS app designed around templates and simplicity. It covers 90% of use cases with less setup and a cleaner interface.
- Both apps watch folders and take automated actions on files. Both run in the background and support rules-based organization.
- Your choice depends on whether you need Hazel's advanced scripting or prefer AutoShelf's modern, template-driven approach.
Feature comparison
Hazel details as of October 2026, from Noodlesoft's site and manual.
| Feature | AutoShelf | Hazel |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free with one rule, $19.99 one-time for unlimited | $42 one-time, $65 Family Pack, $20 upgrade (Hazel 6) |
| Modern macOS design | Yes, native SwiftUI, iOS-like UX | Classic System Settings-style interface |
| Built-in templates | Yes, 5 templates for common use cases | No, create rules from scratch |
| Regex support | Not yet (planned) | Yes |
| Download source routing | Yes | Yes, via Source URL, if the downloading app saves it |
| Download app detection | Yes | No |
| Image optimization | Yes | No |
| Minimum macOS | macOS 14 Sonoma | macOS 13 Ventura (Hazel 6.1) |
| Apple Silicon native | Yes | Yes |
| Menu bar app | Yes | Yes |
| Folder nesting | In development | Yes |
| Webhooks | No | No |
| AppleScript support | No | Yes |
| Shell script actions | No | Yes |
| Condition operators | Simple (match all/any) | Advanced (regex, nesting) |
| Trial | Free with one rule, no time limit | 14-day trial |
| Offline | Yes | Yes |
| Confirmation mode | Yes | No |
| Delay before action | Yes | Yes |
Why choose AutoShelf
Modern, native design
AutoShelf looks and feels like a modern macOS app. Built with SwiftUI, it follows Apple's latest design conventions and supports dark mode natively.
One-time purchase
As of October 2026, Hazel costs $42 per license. AutoShelf is free with one rule and $19.99 one-time for unlimited rules. No subscription, no hidden fees.
Templates for instant setup
AutoShelf includes 5 built-in templates for the most common use cases. Enable one and you are done in seconds instead of building a rule from scratch.
Download source and app detection
Both apps can match the source URL a file was downloaded from. AutoShelf can also match the app that downloaded the file, which Hazel does not offer as a condition.
Image optimization built-in
AutoShelf can automatically compress and optimize images. In Hazel this requires a separate tool or a script.
Free to try, no time limit
AutoShelf is free with one rule indefinitely. Hazel's 14-day trial requires you to decide quickly or pay up front.
When Hazel is the better choice
- You need regex-based filename matching for complex rule conditions
- You rely on AppleScript or shell script actions for custom automation
- You need advanced nesting and folder hierarchy creation in your rules
- You are already a Hazel power user with an existing rule library
Frequently asked questions
-
Is AutoShelf a good Hazel alternative?
Yes. AutoShelf covers the most common file organization use cases with a modern, simpler interface. It is an excellent alternative for users who do not need Hazel's advanced regex and scripting.
-
Can AutoShelf import Hazel rules?
Not directly. AutoShelf and Hazel use different rule architectures. However, AutoShelf's built-in templates cover most common Hazel use cases.
-
Is AutoShelf cheaper than Hazel?
Yes. AutoShelf is free with one rule and $19.99 one-time for unlimited rules. As of October 2026, Hazel costs $42 per license. AutoShelf is also free to try with no time limit.
-
Does AutoShelf support regex?
Not yet. If you need regex-based rules today, Hazel may be the better choice.