CleanMyMac cleans junk. AutoShelf organizes files.
CleanMyMac is a great disk cleaner. But it does not automatically sort your downloads, delete DMG files, or route files by where they came from. AutoShelf watches your folders and keeps them organized in real time. No manual cleanup needed. And it costs $19.99 once instead of about $39.95 per year.
Download for MacPublished · Updated
Which is better, AutoShelf or CleanMyMac?
They solve different problems, so it depends on what you need. If you want to free up disk space, remove system junk, and scan for malware, CleanMyMac is the better choice. If you want new files sorted, renamed, tagged, or deleted automatically as they arrive, AutoShelf is the better choice, because CleanMyMac has no rules-based file organization. Many people use both. As of October 2026, CleanMyMac Basic costs about $39.95 per year for 1 Mac, and AutoShelf is free with 1 rule or $19.99 one-time for unlimited rules.
AutoShelf vs CleanMyMac
CleanMyMac details as of October 2026. Prices vary by region and store.
| Feature | AutoShelf | CleanMyMac |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free with one rule, $19.99 one-time | About $39.95/year (Basic, 1 Mac), or about $119.95 one-time |
| File organization | Yes, rules-based automation | No |
| Auto-delete DMG files | Yes | No |
| Sort files by type | Yes | No |
| Sort by download source | Yes | No |
| Sort by downloading app | Yes | No |
| Image optimization | Yes | No |
| Disk cleanup | No | Yes |
| Malware scanning | No | Yes |
| Mac maintenance | No | Yes |
| Menu bar app | Yes | Yes |
| Apple Silicon native | Yes | Yes |
| Free tier | Yes, one rule free forever | No, free trial only |
| Offline | Yes | Yes |
CleanMyMac does not organize anything
- CleanMyMac is a cleaner, not an organizer. It removes junk files but does not prevent clutter from happening in the first place.
- Your Downloads folder stays messy because CleanMyMac has no rules engine. It cleans what already exists, but new files keep piling up.
- As of October 2026, CleanMyMac Basic costs about $39.95 per year. AutoShelf is free with one rule and $19.99 one-time for unlimited rules. No subscription.
- CleanMyMac does not sort files by type, source, or the app that downloaded them. AutoShelf does all three automatically.
AutoShelf does what CleanMyMac does not
Auto-delete DMGs and installers
AutoShelf trashes .dmg, .pkg, and .mpkg files the moment they land in your Downloads folder. CleanMyMac only finds them after the fact.
Sort files by type
Route images to an Images folder, PDFs to Documents, videos to Movies. AutoShelf builds the folders and sorts new files automatically.
Sort by download source
Files from GitHub go to Developer, from Slack to Work, from Figma to Design. AutoShelf reads download URL metadata automatically.
Sort by downloading app
Safari, Chrome, Arc, Slack. AutoShelf knows which app downloaded each file and can route them to different folders.
Image optimization
AutoShelf can automatically compress JPGs and PNGs. CleanMyMac does not offer image optimization at all.
One-time purchase
AutoShelf costs $19.99 once. As of October 2026, CleanMyMac Basic costs about $39.95 every year. Over 5 years, you save over $175.
You can use both. They do different things.
- AutoShelf organizes files as they arrive. CleanMyMac cleans system junk and malware. They serve different purposes.
- If your Mac is slow and cluttered with system junk, CleanMyMac helps. If your folders are a mess of unsorted files, AutoShelf helps.
- Many users run both: CleanMyMac for monthly maintenance and AutoShelf for daily file organization.
- But if you only care about keeping your Downloads and Desktop clean and organized, AutoShelf does everything you need.
Frequently asked questions
-
Is AutoShelf a good CleanMyMac alternative?
For file organization, yes. AutoShelf automatically sorts, moves, and deletes files based on rules. CleanMyMac is a disk cleaner and malware scanner. They serve different purposes, but if your main goal is keeping your Mac organized, AutoShelf is the better choice.
-
Can I use AutoShelf and CleanMyMac together?
Yes. AutoShelf handles file organization, CleanMyMac handles system maintenance. They target different problems and work well side by side.
-
Is AutoShelf cheaper than CleanMyMac?
Yes. AutoShelf is free with one rule and $19.99 one-time for unlimited rules. As of October 2026, CleanMyMac Basic costs about $39.95 per year. Over 5 years, AutoShelf saves you over $175.
-
Does AutoShelf clean junk files like CleanMyMac?
AutoShelf does not scan for system junk or malware. It auto-organizes files by moving, renaming, tagging, and trashing them based on rules you define. For disk cleaning, you would still need CleanMyMac or a similar tool.